top of page

When Everything Has to Look Perfect—Checks in the Spirit

10 minutes ago
5 min read

This is the first article in a series on the checks in the spirit I experienced during my years in an unhealthy church.


Years ago, I lived with checks in my spirit about the church I was part of: quiet whispers that something I was seeing didn’t line up with what I knew to be true of God and of the gospel. Over the next ten years, those occasional whispers became constant shouts. At the time, I couldn’t have named them, so I wrote most of them off as personality differences with the lead pastor.


I can now name several of them. This series takes them one at a time, in the hope that naming them will help someone else recognize and respond to the whispers sooner than I did.


The first is this: everything had to look perfect.


On its face, that doesn't sound like a warning sign. We were a growing church plant doing work for God, and of course God deserves our best. As part of the leadership team, I believed in excellence, and I worked hard for it. Doing well felt like a way of honoring Him.


But somewhere along the way, the standard shifted from offering our best to appearing flawless. Those are not the same thing. Offering your best still leaves room to say, "This isn't working," or "I'm not doing well." Appearing flawless does not.


I served on the tech team, and I remember the enormous amount of manpower that went toward perfecting the stage lighting and videography. Many times, significant effort was put toward making sure the lead pastor had the perfect look on stage. That effort went beyond the stage. It centered on creating a perfect image of the church itself. In public, nothing negative was ever mentioned. It felt as though everything said about the church needed to praise our growth and the lead pastor’s success.


Offering your best still leaves room to say, "This isn't working," or "I'm not doing well."

On the leadership team, I saw what is true of every ministry behind the scenes: the normal dysfunction, disagreements, and failures. I remember grappling with those. But we were clearly warned never to share any of it from the stage or with anyone outside the leadership team. And the lead pastor never spoke of his personal struggles, or the struggles of the ministry, to the membership of the church.


Some of that may sound normal. Every church wants its services to go well, and not every disagreement belongs in front of the congregation. 


What came next did not.


As the church grew from a small new plant to more than a thousand weekly attendees in just a few years, the growth was talked about constantly from the stage. Our growth rate was regularly shown and compared against the churches that were closing their doors. Other local churches were critiqued because they weren't growing the way we were. Eventually, this led to teaching within leadership circles that other local leaders and their churches probably weren't real believers, because they didn't have the "fruit" that our church had.


The pressure to be perfect was hiding two things.


The first was the true state of the ministry. When only the wins are allowed on stage, the congregation never gets an accurate picture of their church. As an engineer, I know that a system that never reports a problem is not necessarily healthy. More often, it means that no one is looking, or worse: no one is allowed to say what they see.


The second was the true state of the people. When weakness isn't welcome, people learn to hide it. We showed up exhausted and said we were fine. Struggles that should have been brought into the open and tended instead stayed quiet, because admitting that you were struggling felt like you were failing the mission..


The check in my spirit was that gap: the distance between what we presented and what I knew to be true. I didn't have words for why it bothered me. Paul did.


Second Corinthians is written to a church that was impressed by impressive people. A group of leaders Paul calls "super apostles" (2 Corinthians 11:5) had won the Corinthians over, and next to them, Paul didn't measure up. His critics said, "Paul's letters are demanding and forceful, but in person he is weak, and his speeches are worthless!" (2 Corinthians 10:10).


The check in my spirit was the distance between what we presented and what I knew to be true.

If anyone ever had a reason to polish his image, it was Paul in that moment. Instead, he opens the letter by telling them how bad things had been: "We were crushed and overwhelmed beyond our ability to endure, and we thought we would never live through it" (2 Corinthians 1:8). He describes himself and those who served with him as "fragile clay jars containing this great treasure," and he explains why that matters: "This makes it clear that our great power is from God, not from ourselves" (2 Corinthians 4:7). When he finally does boast, he says, "I would rather boast about the things that show how weak I am" (2 Corinthians 11:30).


Paul also names what he is up against: "those who brag about having a spectacular ministry rather than having a sincere heart" (2 Corinthians 5:12). And he tells the Corinthians plainly what following those leaders has cost them: "You put up with it when someone enslaves you, takes everything you have, takes advantage of you, takes control of everything, and slaps you in the face" (2 Corinthians 11:20).

That is a hard verse to read. The Corinthians were more comfortable with impressive leaders who took advantage of them than with a weak apostle who told them the truth. I understand that more than I would like to.


A church that cannot admit weakness has moved the attention from the treasure to the jar.


This is why perfectionism in a church is more than exhausting. When the jar has to look flawless, people end up admiring the jar. And once the image is what holds everything together, the image has to be protected, which means the truth about the ministry and the truth about its people have to stay hidden. Paul's way runs in the other direction. The cracks are where it becomes clear whose power it really is.

When Paul begged God to take away his own weakness, the answer he received was, "My grace is all you need. My power works best in weakness" (2 Corinthians 12:9). God's power works best in the very thing we were working so hard to hide.


A church that cannot admit weakness has moved the attention from the treasure to the jar.

If you find yourself in a church where the stories are always victories, and you hear a whisper that says this isn't the whole truth, listen. Ask yourself a few questions. Is it safe to be weak here? Can a leader say, "I was wrong"? Can someone say that a ministry isn't working, or that they aren't doing well, without it being treated as a lack of faith or loyalty? Then go to scripture and look at how your experience lines up with the words of Jesus, with the ministry we see in the New Testament, and with the fruit of the Spirit (Galatians 5:22-23). Talk with believers you trust, including some who are outside that community.

And if you have already come out of a place like that feeling worn down and far from perfect, take heart. You don't have to be impressive for God to use you. He has always kept His treasure in clay jars.


In the next article in this series, I'll look at another check in the spirit: Isolation from Outside Voices


Chris first wrote about these checks in Who Are You Following?.

 
 

The Way Home is a donor and reader-supported 501(c)(3) nonprofit.
Amazon Affiliate participant | Surveys created through Question Pro

Privacy Policy  |  Disclaimers  |  Accessibility  |  In the News

©2026 BY THE WAY HOME MINISTRIES, INC.  ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

bottom of page